On February 5, the Muslim Public Affairs Committee circulated the following announcement.
L.A. Muslim-Jewish Text Study Program Now Accepting Applications
February 05, 2009
The Text Study Program will use Islamic and Judaic religious texts to promote religious understanding, facilitate dialogue, and enhance participants' knowledg e of their own faith through context, comparison and discussion.
The program will be led by Jihad Turk (the Director of Religious Affairs at the Islamic Center of Southern California, a Religious Director at USC, and a PhD candidate in Islamic Studies at the UCLA) and Reuven Firestone (professor of Medieval Judaism and Islam at Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion in Los Angeles and senior fellow at USC's Center for Religion & Civic Culture). NewGround co-directors Aziza Hasan and Malka Fenyvesi will also serve as program facilitators.
- Click here to download the text study application (Word Document)
- To request the application by email, please email: cmje@usc.edu
- All applicants are encouraged to apply by: February 13, 2009
The Center for Muslim-Jewish Engagement & NewGround Text Study Pilot Program is made possible by the support of the Center for Religion and Civic Culture at the University of Southern California, the Omar Ibn Al Khattab Foundation, the Muslim Public Affairs Council, the Progressive Jewish Alliance, and Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion.
Today, non-Jews should only meet with Jewish groups to demand that Jews apply to themselves the same standard that they apply to everyone else.
In other words, just as Jews demand that non-Jews acknowledge, take responsibility for, and show remorse for the anti-Jewish crimes that have arisen from non-Jewish politics, Jews must likewise acknowledge, take responsibility for and show remorse for the anti-gentile crimes that have arisen from Jewish politics.
There really is no value in talking with Jews that do not admit that Zionism is ethnic Ashkenazi Nazism, that the State of Israel routinely engages in terrorism, and that the only just solution consist of the dismantlement of the Zionist state, the eradication of Zionism, trials for Jewish perpetrators of crimes against humanity, repatriation of the native population, and reconveyance of properties to their rightful owners.
Here is my open letter to the organizers of this latest silly Muslim-Jewish interfaith dialogue.
From: thorsprovoni@aol.com
To: communications@mpac.org; turk@islamctr.org; aziza@newgroundproject.org; mfenyvesi@newgroundproject.org
Sent: Tue, 10 Feb 2009 8:04 am
Subject: Re: L.A. Muslim-Jewish Text Study Program Now Accepting Applications
It is quite intellectually dishonest because it does not address the transformation of traditional Jewish religion into a combination of ethnic narcissism, Holocaust obsession, and worship of the State of Israel on the basis of völkisch racist politics.
For the vast majority of Jews the texts under consideration are for the most part irrelevant.
A useful course would look at Central and Eastern European Jewish political nationalist texts and discuss the development of ethnic fundamentalist and ethnic monist ideas among German Jews and ethnic Ashkenazim.
The modern Jewish American consciousness has much in common with the German Nazi mentality of the 1930s, and in fact, the primary Zionist ideologist Max Nordau is at least as influential among German Nazis as he was among Zionists (ethnic Ashkenazi Nazis).
I know that Jewish racists and extremists generally consider it offensive to discuss Jewish Nazism, but when Zionist forces so casually slaughter non-Jewish women and children as happened during the latest IDF rampage in Gaza, we have to get past such Zionist mental colonization.
To believe that Jews of all people could not develop their own Nazi ideology comparable to German Nazism is itself a racist belief in Jewish ethical superiority to the rest of the human race.
Just as racist murderous genocidal Zionist Jewish invaders, interlopers, and thieves in Stolen and Occupied Palestine threaten the non-Jewish populations of the ME, Zionist Jewish power threatens American Muslims with at least marginalization and undermines the fabric of American society, politics and culture.
My document The Israel Lobby and American Society addresses both
- the danger of the Israel Lobby, which is the public face of the Zionist Virtual Colonial Motherland, and also
- the development of a Jewish power system that intimidates the entire human race.
- who fail to condemn Jewish racism and extremism categorically and
- who refuse to demand the abolition of the Zionist state along with the arrest, trial and punish of Zionist war criminals.
If you are interested, please send me an email.
Sincerely yours,
Joachim Martillo
P.S. Here is an excerpt from my document on Issues and Questions in the Historiography of Pre-State Zionism.
The Medieval Anachronism:
יהודים, 'Iουδαϊοι, Iūdaei and اليهود Become Jews
(Origins of Modern Rabbinic Judaism)
Anachronism Upon Anachronism:
Eastern European Jews Become Ashkenazim
(Origins of the Autochthonous Eastern European Ashkenazi Ethnic Group)
- France and the UK, belonging wholly to the area of the Treaty, developed a secular civil or voluntary nationalism according to which citizenship conferred membership in the nation,
- Germans, whose territories came to span the regions of the Treaty and the Rebellion, tended toward secular organic nationalism according to which the individual was analogous to a cell in the organic body of the nation and the state was identified with a specific ethnonational group, and
- Eastern Europeans including Ashkenazim developed a confessional organic nationalism according to which the specific ethnonational group to which the state belongs was strictly defined on confessiona l boundaries even though religious belief declined precipitously among Eastern Europeans during the 19th, 20th and 21st centuries.
In the Modern Period: Not only Anachronism But Also Exceptionalism and Omission
The Known Facts
The Scary Story
Exceptionalism and Omission: A Fantasy Pretending to Be History
Zeev Sternhell
Yosef Gorny
Because Germany and Austria had no imperial possessions, German Orientalism of the Ancient and Modern Middle East or India was generally accounted a subspecialty of Classics and therefore tended to relegate even modern Arabic cultures to a non-living status.[49] German Ashkenazi Zionists stee ped in German Semitics had no problems in denying the national and human rights of the members of dead cultures. German Indology, which had a direct input into Nazi theories of Aryan superiority, probably also had indirect influence on Zionism through the idea of Umvolkung or population supplantation as it developed in extremist German nationalist discourse to justify the displacement of inferior races.
The Consequences of Zionist Historiography
The failings and distortions associated with the Zionist historiography, of which Sternhell and Gorny are in some sense the best examples, have obvious consequences and repercussions for American historical and political debate as well as the popular culture from which most Americans learn their history and develop their political choices.
…what people learned from … the writers of history books…
… what people learned from … television programmes [and movies] …
The ill effects of Zionist control of the political and historical discourse hardly cease with pre-college education. Americans are constantly bombarded with false and racist depictions of the conflict in the Middle East by the popular media. No one should wonder why American political leaders consistently side with Zionists on the question of Palestine. The following partial list of American produced and directed non-documentary non-docudrama feature films,[55] that specifically mention Israel, Israelis, Palestine or Palestinians, shows how much Hollywood and American Indie (Independent) cinema culture has assimilated or absorbed Zionist myths, attitudes and beliefs into its products for dissemination into the American and world market. [56],[xxvii] No Hollywood or American Indie studio has ever produced a feature film with a Palestinian point of view (viz Figure 5). In fact, the films reviewed contain a plethora of images and scenes in which Palestinians or Arabs kill countless innocent non-combatants while Israelis never kill Palestinian or non-Palestinian innocents, a record that even the US military and special forces cannot match in American film.
Ben-Hur (1959, MGM) contains a tremendous amount of metaphorical Zionist propaganda. The oppressive Roman Empire represents the British Empire, against which the Americanized Jewish[57] hero must struggle. The Arab Sheikh Ilderim is portrayed as effeminate and subordinate -- almost a second Esther in his relationship to Judah Ben-Hur.It is a screen representation of the Zionist propaganda that national liberation of the Jews (i.e., stealing Palestine from the Palestinians) will bring liberation of the Arabs albeit as subordinates to the Jews. This movie sets the standard for very subtle and very effective Zionist indoctrination.[58]
Solomon and Sheba (1959, MGM/UA) targets Ashkenazi Americans and superficial Zionistically-inclined biblical literalists.Anachronism is pervasive in this film. The Star of David was completely unknown as an ancient "Israelite," Judean or even Jewish symbol until the last few hundred years. As a Jewish symbol, before Zionism the hexagram is associated mostly with Sabbatian and perhaps Frankist heresies. Yet, the troops of King David and King Solomon wear Stars of David on their uniforms, and it serves as a decoration throughout the film.King Solomon, who is played by Yul Brynner, repeats all sorts of Zionist slogans throughout the movie, and the geopolitical situation described in the movie is obviously constructed to reflect the situation of the State of Israel in the 1950s.Nevertheless, it is intriguing that the director, whose conceptualization of story the movie ultimately reflects, was King Vidor. King Vidor was one of the most talented of Hollywood directors. He directed the Wizard of Oz. He also had strong connection to Premillennial Dispensationalist Christianity. He grew up in Vidor, Texas, which was founded by his father C. S. Vidor. This town is still noted for irredentist unreconstructed Confederate attitudes, apocalyptic evangelical fundamentalism, KKK connections and extreme racism. It is also very typical bedrock Texas community of the sort the supports George Bush.
Solomon and Sheba was not a blockbuster, but it did make money and was perhaps symptomatic of things yet to come.
Exodus (1960, UA)[xxviii] is practically a course in Zionist הסברה or propaganda. It goes through practically all the standard false claims to justify Zionist Ashkenazi colonization and aggression against the native population of Palestine. The movie leaves out the book's characterizations of Arabs as smelly or dirty, but it does include the de rigueur association of Nazis with the anti-Zionist resistance. In point of fact Labor Zionists themselves tried very hard to work with Nazi Germany and did so fairly effectively until 1939 while al-Hussayni was fairly quickly dispatched to Bosnia, where he did not speak the language, when he finally tried to approach Germany for aid.
Both the director Otto Preminger and the author Leon Uris had many revisionist associations. Therefore, it is not too surprising that Exodus contains a Jabotinskian or Revisionist justification of Zionist terrorism that in 2002 underscores the hypocrisy of the Israeli and American Ashkenazi reactions to legitimate terrorism against the State of Israel. Like most Hollywood movies that contain the theme of nation creation, the movie ends with a poignant sacrifice for the sake of the nation. Exodus is particularly creative in this regard because one of the martyrs on behalf of Zionism is a Zionist Arab. Exodus is exceptionally explicit in sending the message that the USA should get in bed with Israel.United Artists had a fair amount of success with Exodus and tried once again with Cast a Giant Shadow (1966, UA).This movie gives the story of Colonel Mickey Marcus, who was recruited by the Haganah, the Labor Zionist militia, to provide operational expertise. Marcus conveniently dies in 1948 so that the film can have the typical ending for films of nation creation. The movie lectures the viewer in the standard Labor Zionist הסברה but goes one step beyond Exodus to argue that American Ashkenazim should serve Israeli interests. The beginning of the movie is worth watching. It goes through all the standard Zionist propaganda that is still repeated in American schools, universities and media to this day. It portrays the Ashkenazi settlement as outnumbered although it was not. It claims Arab leaders made statements that are mostly impossible to verify. It claims that the Ashkenazim had no place to go even though the Ashkenazi displaced persons could have been resettled fairly easily within a few years while most of the Ashkenazi settlers in Palestine would probably have been happy for the colony to be dismantled. Major Safir, the Zionist emissary, makes the obligatory emotional pitch about the threat to the Ashkenazim in Palestine so that Marcus will only react reflexively rather than think rationally about the claims Safir makes because otherwise a little reflection might have lead to the revelation that the native population has just as much claim to liberty and justice as the Ashkenazi settler colonists. At the time Safir is supposed to give his speech, Zionist forces have already begun their ethnic cleansing of Palestine.
- Videoclip 1 and Videoclip 2 from the next film, Black Sunday (1977, Paramount), are rather more interesting. Not only is this movie the first action adventure film that combines the Israel-Palestine conflict with Neoconservative political thinking, but also this movie looks in retrospective exceptionally prophetic after the September 11 attack on the World Trade Center. One might hypothesize that Usama bin Ladin was inspired by the imagination of Thomas Harris, the author of Black Sunday as well as Red Dragon, The Silence of the Lambs and Hannibal.
Michael Lander is a disgraced US Air Force pilot that plots with the help of Black September to kill 80,000 people and the president of the United States at a Superbowl football game by crashing an explosive laden blimp into the stadium. Because of the similarity of the movie's terrorist operation to the WTC attack, it is worth mention that that no Palestinian group was involved in the September 11 atrocity and that the perpetrators were members of an extremist group loosely associated with the Egyptian Muslim brotherhood (المسلمون الإخوان), which has its own distinct and often legitimate grievances against the USA. Such complaints, as Palestinians and other Arabs can make against the USA, do not interest Harris, who focuses mostly on the psychopathology of the killer. Palestinians, the Middle East conflict and Black September are mostly props in his book. Harris suggested a possible connection of Black September to Vietnamese communists by means of a videotape of Lander s confession to war crimes while he was a POW during the Vietnam war. The screenwriter made the connection to international anti-Americanism by explicitly portraying collaboration with Japanese terrorists.
Both the movie and the book are somewhat unique in that they begin with murders of Arabs by an Israeli death squad in Lebanon. Normally, Israeli terror squads are portrayed as retaliating for some on-screen act of violence, but Harris' lack of interest in Middle East issues may have immunized him to some extent to the common Zionist attitudes that most Americans have adopted.[59] Nevertheless, the terrorist act itself corresponds far more to Zionist mythology than to actual Palestinian operations at the time, which generally confined themselves to the seizure of hostages or airplanes to secure the release of prisoners that were held by Israelis under torture and the threat of execution at any time.
The director and the scriptwriter went beyond the book to explore motivations and the cause of the conflict. In the movie Major Kabokov, the Israeli protagonist, suffers from the usual "whack 'em and weep syndrome." Harris and the screenwriter portray such as qualms as explicitly negative in conformance with the Neoconservative ideology that is developing at the time. If Kabokov had not shown mercy toward Dahlia Iyad in Beirut, the Black September attack would have been stopped before it could even stop.
Kabokov's self-doubts belong to the films subtheme of recovering masculinity. The US agents are paralyzed by procedures and rules that prevent them from taking the necessary action to stop the terrorists. Lander's masculinity has been permanently damaged by his imprisonment in Vietnam. The paralysis of US intelligence agents and Lander's impotence serve as fairly obvious metaphors for the Vietnam syndrome. Lander uses the wrong methods to overcome his sexual dysfunction by sexual and terrorist collaboration with Iyad, who lends Lander evil power by means of Arab sensuality and seduction. She makes Lander hard and tou gh once again as she directs him to undertake a terrorist attack on behalf of Black September. In contrast, when Kabokov overcomes his self-doubts in response to the killing of his partner and thwarts the terror attack, he becomes in conformance with Neoconservative ideology the forceful Israeli that teaches Americans how to deal with foreign and in particular Arab threats.
The scenes of the auditing of the Black September post-attack tape and of the identification of the Dahlia Iyad by Egyptian security are worth reviewing. The message that Iyad reads is far more powerful in the movie than in the book while the identification scene was created for the movie.
One can only speculate why it was necessary in the movie to identify Iyad as an Arab of German Palestinian extraction. Perhaps after showing some sympathy with Palestinian suffering, the director might have felt an obligation to pander Zionist myth of the Arab German link in the opposition to Zionism. Or perhaps, the director just needed explain the portrayal of a Palestinian woman by an actress of German extraction.
I also have to wonder whether the director was reluctant from the start to portray Arabs as relentlessly negative as Harris wrote in the book. While there could have been some last minute editing of the film in response to Sadat's peace initiative, there might be a subtle indoctrination that the validity of Arab or Palestinian grievance is irrelevant. Arabs and Palestinians are too dangerous, and the coalition of Americans and Israelis must crush them without mercy in all their schemes.
The movie's ending differs significantly from that of the book. While Harris' book is on the whole rather flawed, his denouement in which Kabokov sacrifices himself to stop Iyad and Lander would have created a far superior climax for the movie. A powerful cinematic ending seems to have been sacrificed to the desire to provide a triumphalist Neoconservative conclusion to the film.Time after Time (1979, WB) also repeats the standard Zionist lie that Palestinian terrorists committed senseless violence against masses of innocent civilians. None of the references to completely fictional Palestinian terrorism have any intrinsic connection to the plot but serve almost as a subliminal indoctrination of the audience. This sort of incidental propagandization of the American public is probably more sinister than the thematic use of Zionist myth, which is more obvious and easier to dismiss as obvious nonsense.
Golda (1982, Paramount) is a biography of Gold Meir that is mostly hero worship and Labor Zionist הסברה. The descriptions of the issues of Palestinian refugees and of access to Jerusalem are simply dishonest. The movie probably correctly but accidentally portrays Meir as a person that lacks any ethical awareness, understanding and impulses. In the clip presented she has the nerve to ask the self-serving question what population could remain a refugee population for 30 years even though she herself is the leader of the movement that made them refugees and even though the Zionist movement justifies its seizure of Palestine by means of the primordialist argument that Jews have been refugees for 2000 years.
Hanna K. (1983, Universal) is fascinating because of the timidity that Costa-Gavras shows in portraying ethically dubious Zionist beliefs, actions and behavior. The movie depicts problems in the life of an attorney loosely modeled on Felicia Langer. She is defending a Palestinian infiltrator. According to its own internal documentation, the IDF usually simply shoots unarmed infiltrators, but the director and writer uncritically accepts the Zionist viewpoint that Israel actually has a functioning legal system and that Zionists actually make effort to deal with difficult ethical questions as well as they can.[60]Because the film concedes the possibility that aspects of Zionism might have morally problematic effects, major public con troversy accompanied general distribution. The clip shows Hanna, the prosecutor and the judge as they attempt to find an extra-juridical solution to the problem that the defendant presents. Note how the judge makes the usual irrational and unethical Zionist arguments to justify Zionism while he uses the usual psychological triggers about the Nazi persecutions to intimidate Hanna into accepting his viewpoint.
Hanna K. like Torn Apart[61] (1990, Warner Studios) and Double Edge[62] (1991, Faye Milano Limited Partnership) represents a sort of Liberal Israeli or Ashkenazi American fantasy, in which the Zionist heroes really are moral people that strive to overcome obstacles and do right in difficult situations. Such movies do not address the possibility that Zionism might be fundamentally ethically questionable. The depiction of Palestinians in these films corresponds to fantasies about Palestinians from Zionist narratives or propaganda and not to any sort of discernible reality. While individual Israeli settler colonists may be obnoxious or defend themselves violently in the course of the plot, only Palestinians ever commit crimes or aggression in this class of film.[63]
Little Drummer Girl (1984, WB) was also released with a major controversy, which in retrospect is hard to understand, for the movie is similar to Black Sunday except for less examination of motivations. The movie begins with a Palestinian terrorist attack so that Israeli actions can be portrayed as legitimate retaliation. Even though the members of the Israeli hit team are particularly unpleasant as they murder and use non-Jews in order to track down and assassinate an important Black September leader, Zionist self-perception and claims are never challenged. In the course of the story the Palestinian terrorists specifically target an Israeli peace advocate, and the movie includes some "whack 'em and weep" Zionist blubbering.
Oh God! You Devil (1984, WB) really demoni zes Arafat. The devil comments that he has had Arafat's soul for years. As far as 3rd world national liberation leaders go, Arafat does not seem much different from Kwame Nkrumah, Jomo Kenyatta, Ahmed Ben Bella, etc. His demonization in the USA is particularly incomprehensible except as a symptom of the pervasive assimilation by Americans of the Zionist point of view.
Splash (1984, Touchstone Pictures). Schindler's List (1993, Universal) is unprecedented as an expression of extremist nationalist Likud הסברה. We know that the story is fundamentally a nation creation narrative because the movie ends with the death of Schindler to show that the people he lead became capable of standing on the own. This movie proved to be a genuine blockbuster[64] unlike earlier Zionist oriented films that were only moderately successful. Obviously, no one visits the cinemaplex for a lecture in Labor Zionist ideology.
This film is extremely problematic on several grounds. It is a consciously inverted film noir Wizard of Oz that markets its message subliminally. The evil of Nazism is reduced to psychopathology. Zionist ideologues prefer such an understanding of Nazism because genu ine analysis of the phenomenon of Nazism would find too many similarities to Zionism. As history, the movie embodies the serious failures of Zionist historiography to which Hobsbawm referred. The movie describes the Holocaust of Zionist myth not the historical שואה (or catastrophe). The Soviet officer makes the pitch of a שליח (a Zionist emissary that recruits new immigrants).
One must wonder how a Palestinian would view the conclusion. It shows the Schindler Jews, who mostly did not migrate to Palestine, as they step into a rebirth of color and into Jerusalem to the sound in the background of זהב של ירושלים, a song that celebrates the culmination of a series of dispossession, tragedies and expulsions of the native population and that is generally associated now with the extreme right in Israeli politics.[65]Spielberg is indoctrinating the audience with the f ollowing propaganda.
I am not surprised that the Egyptian and many other governments had some serious issues with subjecting their populations to this sort of blatant Zionist propaganda.There are a lot of ethical problems associated with the UN recommendation to partition Palestine along völkisch principles that violated the UN charter and that wronged the native population. Universal Studies should have given the film a voluntary NC-17 rating, for it is certainly wrong to indoctrinate young people and children with the idea that two wrongs make a right.This ending was so close to the Likud formula for "national ritual assertion of Israel state identity and superiority" and conformed so exactly to the "central item of the official system of national beliefs" as promulgated by the Likud party that the ending had to be modified for Israeli audiences. USA popular culture has an even higher tolerance of the most extremist Zionist myth and propaganda than Israeli Jews do. One must wonder whether the success of such clever Likud propaganda at the box office presaged the failure of the Oslo Process.[xxix]
Conclusion
Zionist Intimidation and McCarthyism: Anti-Semitism, Judeophobia and Justified Hostility
The Evil That Zionism has created
What is to Be Done?
At the Local Level
What People Of Jewish or Ashkenazi Ancestry Can Do
Sphere: Related Content



