To the Editor:
Laura Bermen writes in "Paul eyes the cranky Mich. vote," Detroit News, January 3, 2003.
Paul, an obstetrician-turned-lawmaker, hates taxes, sloppy immigration policies, abortion, and the loss of the gold currency standard. His campaign rhetoric goes heavy on "freedom." He exudes a twangy "Mr. Smith Goes to Washington" authenticity that college students, libertarians, Ayn Randians, and the usual suspect fringe of survivalists and neo-Nazis find appealing.
Before I learned about the media update sessions that the organized Jewish community provides to reporters to explain how they should cover the news, I used to think that Berman's sort of snide, insinuating and misleading comment was just ignorance.
Why did Berman not mention as a way of defining a baseline of comparison that we do not have to look at the "fringe" supporters of Giuliani to find reasons for concern about the Giuliani campaign. Giuliani's chief advisors are far scarier than anyone supporting Ron Paul. For example, Podhoretz uses the Goebbelsian big lie technique to promote an attack on Iran that will plunge the USA in at least 100 more years of pointless war for the sake of the State of Israel. (See
The Case for Bombing Iran in the June 2007 issue of
Commentary.)
Why did Berman not tell Detroit News readers what Nazism is before accusing some subgroup of Paul supporters of being Nazis?
Nazism is a form of politicized ethnic fundamentalism that combines racism, extremist organic nationalism, biological determinism, eugenics, theories of national decline through race-mixing, concepts of national revival through racial purity, social Darwinism, essentialism, and primordialism. It was particularly prevalent in Central and Eastern Europe during the WW1-WW2 inter bellum period until the end of WW2. Nazism made a brief come-back in a revival of Greater Serbianism in post-Soviet Yugoslavia.
Nazi and fascist ideologies differ. Fascism is an extremist organic nationalist revision of Marxist socialism. According to fascist theory, national revival provides the means to transcend the class conflict. Nazism and fascism can coexist. The Strasser faction of German Nazism was inclined to fascism while some forms of fascism that incorporate racist ideas often developed Nazi tendencies.
Today, Nazi ideology remains a vital, dominant and dangerous ideology only in the State of Israel. In stolen Palestine (pre-1967 Israel) and occupied Palestine, the Zionist invader population has for the last 60 years pursued a program of genociding the native population right before the eyes of the world with 80% support levels (according to American Jewish Committee statistics) among ethnic Ashkenazi Americans.
Berman fails to report such essential information while she uses guilt by alleged and tenuous association to delegitimize the candidacy of Ron Paul, who questions any US obligation to pay trillions of dollars as foreign aid to maintain the State of Israel. Because Berman is propagandizing instead of reporting, the Detroit News should fire Berman summarily and replace her with someone, who does not consciously or reflexively twist news reports for the sake of an ethnic agenda.
Sincerely yours,
Thursday, January 3, 2008
Laura Berman:
Paul eyes the cranky Mich. vote
Even if the New York Pekingese meet-up currently lists more online members than the Metro Detroiters for Ron Paul group, the Republican from Texas is investing in Michigan.
And because Michigan investors -- whether political or corporate -- are scarce of late, Paul's recent moves in Michigan are worth looking at.
Last weekend, his campaign opened a Detroit office on Telegraph Road, an event an official campaign press release indicated drew more than 200 people but an observer said attracted less than 50. Paul -- who has both ideas and principles, few of them mainstream or tepid -- sees possibilities in Michigan's cranky voter base, ready to be mobilized for the Jan. 15 primary. As it happens, just the thought of that primary is enough to make any but the most hard-core partisan cranky.
Paul's stock is rising
Given a Democratic primary that's been engineered to produce a Hillary Clinton victory and a Republican primary that's open to disaffected Democrats and independents, Paul is no longer the complete and utter longshot he appeared back in November, when only 2 percent of likely primary-voting Republicans named him as their pick.
Now, he's up to 4 percent, according to an EPIC/MRA poll, and polling 16 percent in Macomb County, where cranky (otherwise known as "independent"), party-crossing voting is a tradition.
Paul, an obstetrician-turned-lawmaker, hates taxes, sloppy immigration policies, abortion, and the loss of the gold currency standard. His campaign rhetoric goes heavy on "freedom." He exudes a twangy "Mr. Smith Goes to Washington" authenticity that college students, libertarians, Ayn Randians, and the usual suspect fringe of survivalists and neo-Nazis find appealing.
Cash surge boosts bid
His promises to seal the nation's borders, end the IRS and the Department of Education and to bring home the troops from Iraq within a few months of his election comprise an ambitious collage of ideas, one backed by an unexpected surge of cash: Paul's campaign received $25 million in donations in 2007, most of it in the final quarter.
"We're flesh and blood supporters," says Scotty Boman, a Detroit college instructor and teacher, who is backing Ron Paul. "We all want more freedom and less government control."
Like other Paul followers, Boman -- a Libertarian who recently joined the Republican Party to back Paul -- says the Texas congressman is the first Republican or Democrat he's wanted to vote for since 1980.
Paul's decision to open a Detroit office bespeaks a real interest in Michigan, if not a full-scale commitment.
As of Wednesday, his new Detroit office did not have a listed telephone number.